A comparative study of phonetogram parameters among female trained Hindustani classical singers, untrained singers and non-singers
Keywords:Phonetogram, Training, Singer, Voice profile range, Speech range profile
Background: Vocal sound is based on the complex yet co-ordinated interaction of phonatory system, resonatory system and respiratory system. Phonetography is a practicable and readily accessible method to investigate and map the quantitative potentialities of vocal output. The objectives of the present study were to determine the phonetogram of trained (Hindustani classical) singers, untrained singer sand non-singers elicited from singing as well as speech task to see if statistically significant differences were present which may indicate an effect of training.
Methods: 90 female subjects between the ages 20-45 (mean age 34.2 years for trained subjects, 26.3 years for untrained subjects and 25.8 years for non-singers) divided into three groups each group consisting of 30 subjects. For the singing task, the individuals had to phonate |a| at habitual level by traversing through eight musical scales. In the speech task, the subjects were asked to count from one to twenty in Bengali at habitat level and at Sustainable cohorts of intensity. This was recorded using phonetogram software Dr. Speech (version 4). The parameters considered were fundamental frequency, intensity, semitones and area.
Results: The study revealed that in both tasks singing and non-singing task for all three groups in all the four parameters of phonetogram significant differences were seen (p=0.000) at 95% level of confidence.
Conclusions: The present study depicted the phonetographic profile of a genre of trained singers and tracked out the parameters on which differences are pronounced between a trained and untrained singer and non-singer.
Titze I. Acoustic interpreattion of the vioce range profile (phonetogram). J Speech Hear Res. 1992;35(1):21-34.
Benninger M, Jacobson B, Johnson A. Disorders of speaking. In: Benninger M, Johnson A, eds. Vocal Arts Medicine: The Care and Prevention of Professional Voice Disorders. New York: Thieme Medical Publications; 1994: 156.
Akerlund L, Gramming P. Average loudness level, mean fundamental frequency, and subglottal pressure: a comparison between female singers and male singers and non-singers. J Voice. 1998:263-70.
Awan SN. Phonetographic profiles and F0-SPL characteristics of untrained versus trained vocal groups. J Voice. 1991;5(1):41-50.
LeBorgne WD, Weinrich BD. Phonetogram changes for trained singers over a nine-month period of vocal training. J Voice. 2002;16:37-43.
Lamarche A, Ternstrom S, Pabon P. The singer’s voice range profile: female professional opera soloists. J Voice. 2010;24(4):410-26.
Sheela EV. Comparative study of vocal parameters of trained and untrained singers. (Unpublished master’s thesis). University of Mysore. Mysore.
Ghosh K. Comparison of Acoustic Characteristics in female-trained (Carnatic style) singers, untrained singers, and non-singers. (Unpublished master’s thesis). University of Mysore. Mysore.
Holmberg EB, Oates J, Dacakis G, Grant C. Phonetograms, aerodynamic measurement, self-evaluations, and auditory perceptual ratings of male to female transsexual voice. J Voice. 2010;24(5):511-22.
Sulter AM, Schutte KH, Miller GD. Differences in phonetogram features between male and female subjects with and without vocal training. J Voice. 1995;9:363-77.
Akerlund L, Gramming P, Sundberg J. Phonetogram and averages of sound pressure levels and fundamental frequencies of speech: comparison between female singers and nonsingers. J Voice. 1992;6(1):55-63.
Awan SN. Superimposition of speaking voice characteristics and phonetograms in trained and untrained vocal groups. J Voice. 1993;7:30-7.
Chattopadhyay D, Chatterjee I, Kumar S. A comparative study of trained and untrained rabindra sangeet singers. In: Dutta AK, Gupta P, Ghosh D, Dasmandal SK, Sengupta R, Dey N, eds. Kolkata, India: Proceedings of the International Symposium of Frontiers Of Research on Speech and Music; 2008: 361-364.
Sulter AM, Wit HP Schutte HK, Miller DG. A structured approach to voice range profile (phonetogram) analysis. J speech Lang Hear Res. 1994;37(5):1076-85.
Gramming P, Sundberg J. Spectrum factors relevant to phonetogram measurement. J Acoust Soc Am. 1988;83:23-60.
Sulter AM, Meijer JM. Effects of voice training on phonetograms and maximum phonation times in female speech therapy students. In: Sulter AM, ed. Variation of voice quality features and aspects of voice training in males and females. Netherlands: Rijkuniversiteit Groningen; 1996: 133-147.
Gould W. The effect of voice training on lung volumes in singers and the possible relationship to the damping factor of Pressman. J Res Sing. 1977;1:3-15.
Watson P, Hixon T. Respiratory kinematics in classical (opera) singing. J Speech Hear Res. 1985;28:104-22.
Hixon T, Hoffman C. Chest wall shape in singing. In: Lawrence VL (Chair), eds. Transcripts of the 7th symposium on the professional voice. New York: The Voice Foundation; 1985: 9-10.